Thursday, November 16, 2017

Wargame Design: New Title: Turf War

The astute reader of this blog will have noticed that the number of Free Wargames has grown on this page!  When I first started there were 6 games available for free there.  That selection has grown a lot in the past year and a half.  It is now a whopping 11.  Not bad productivity for 18 months or so. 

The newest addition to the Blood and Spectacles fold is Turf War a game of 1930’s Gangster battles.  I like this game since it is a skirmish game that allows for campaign play and RPG-lite style scenarios.  It uses the Combat Pool system for combat found in The Games: Blood and Spectacleand Tournament Pageantry and Pain.  However, it also uses pools for other non-combat actions such as smooth-talking, safe-cracking, and other RPG-lite options.  Not everything has to be solved by a flurry of Tommy Gun fire…. but it can be.   



In addition to the Core mechanics of everyday gang warfare Turf War also has a strong campaign system built on the model of some of my favorites such as Necromunda, Strange Aeons, and TheGames: Blood and Spectacle.  Lowly gangsters can gain experience to earn skills, get injured, or improve their abilities.  In addition, the game uses a Turf bidding system prior to games to represent the give and take of territory based on the results of a game.  Resources for your gang are managed such as Reputation, Take, Turf, and Favors.  In addition, the Boss has to manage the recruitment and retention of his gang too.  The game also uses a Most Wanted rating to gauge relative gang strength that allows for catch-up mechanics for those just entering an existing campaign or who have had a run of bad luck. 

Overall, I wanted the game itself to force decisions making, and reward good gameplay.  Sometimes, campaign games focus too much on the campaign and bolt the gameplay on as a secondary concern.  That is not the case with Turf War.  I wanted the game to be full of decisions.  The theme of Turf War is to try and force decision making on a risk vs. reward continuum.  This is primarily accomplished through resource management of dice pools for combat, non-combat, and even activation.  Combat Pool is bid and used to attack and defend, but it will not be replenished until the following turn.  Therefore, as the player you have to decide when is the right time to use it, and how much of it. 

Activation is also a push your luck system as a model can only do one thing per activation such as move, shoot, perform and action, etc. You can risk trying to chain activations together as well.  I used a similar activation system in Combat! Starring Vic Morrow as well.  Failure to activate multiple times risks losing the initiative and allowing your opponent to start activating.  Therefore, additional activations are another risk vs. reward decision point.

The biggest sticking point in completing these rules was coming up with interesting Scored (scenarios) to play.  In the end, I used some “generic” wargames style scenario with some added period flavor.  Inspiration came from StrangeAeons, Mad Dogs with Guns, Pulp Alley, Rogue Trader, and Rogue StarsHowever, there is room to combine or modify the scenarios in the rules and adding more RPG-lite elements is strongly encouraged.

To help kick-off the game, I of course made some paper templates that you can use to get your gangs started.  I also put together a couple of gangs for playtesting.  These should give you a good quick start into games.  They can be found Here on the Messageboard.  


Of course, I have also started picking up a few gangsters here and there to paint.  You probably recognize these Pulp Alley figures from the Painting Desk.  Well, I have one doen to get a start on one of my gangs! 

   

Saturday, November 11, 2017

Random: Aeronautica Imperialis- Tree Campaign


In my last post I talked a bit about what is on the painting desk.  I also opined about how I dislike painting as it is my least favorite part of the hobby.  That hasn’t changed.  However, painting does get my thinking about how I plan to use the models and excited to play again.  This is what I have been working on first, the Varingyr aircraft. 



You can find the rules for these aircraft in the Airspace Rules Compilation.  As I was reviewing the rules for the Warlord Super-Heavy Airship and the Strike Eagle ground support fighter it got the wheels turning.  I think I could string together a few games into a mini-campaign? 
  
For those familiar with the Blood and Irongard campaign you know that the Varingyr(Squats) have a rich history and a developed setting in the Galactic Core.  I admit, I haven’t kept up to date on the “Dark Imperium” setting of 8th edition so I have no idea if the Galactic Core even still exists or was replaced by a warp storm or some such.  However, in the Blood and Irongard campaign we are introduced to the Belt of Varin, a section of the Core that was once home to the Varingyr empire.  However, they fell victim to Imperial aggression and then Genestealer Infestation which led to civil war and destruction on a society shattering scale. 
          
Since those dark days, the Varingyr that remain have been slowly trying to re-build and recover their lost Strongholds.  The enemies were Tyranids beasts, Ork marauders, and even human Rogue Traders.  However, the worst enemy of all was the Genestealer Infected Varingyr held sway by the Ancestor’s Curse.  The idea of reclaiming a lost Stronghold held interesting possibilities for a campaign.

After per using the mission ideas in the Airspace Rules Compilation I started to sketch out a branching campaign.  In this Campaing, the Varingyr have located a former Minehead that has been overrun by Orks.  However, you could also use Rogue Traders, Tyranids, or other opponents.  Naturally, the Varingyr want to reclaim their homeland and launch an attack.  The campaign will determine the success of failure of their forces in reclaiming the Minehead from their foes.  There is still plenty of room for me to fluff the background out if I wish, or leave the basic skeleton in place. 
 
Of course, this campaign is designed to allow me to use my Varingyr aircraft from the humble Iron Eagle to the mighty Warlord Airship.  Feel free to play through it yourself.  The Missions and unit profiles are in the Airspace Rules Compilation and the Cleansing of Grex Silex books.


Oh, by the way I got those Varingyr aircraft models painted up too.  Finishing them inspired me to start putting a campaign together to use them in. 


         

Monday, November 6, 2017

Random: On The Painting Desk

On this blog I rarely talk about the painting or modeling side of things.  Of all the aspects of wargaming it is one of my least favorite aspects.  Clearly, it is not imperative to me as I am more than willing to use Paper Templates to play a game.  However, I am also attracted to the spectacle of wargaming and prefer to have actual painted models when I can.  Sadly, for that to happen that means I have to paint them.  I am no great shakes at painting and do not really enjoy it.   

Recently, I re-read my Goals for 2017 and the progress I had made on them up to July.  I have been making good progress on my playing and designing goals.  The main things that had been holding me back on my 2017 goals were the painting side of things.  With only two months left of the season, I had better get cracking on with some painting if I wanted to improve from July!

Suitably motivated, I went online and finally ordered those Victrix Limited Greeks I was going to need for Men of Bronze.  I ordered enough models, bases, and transfers for 1 Spartan army, 1 Corinthian army, and 1 Macedonian army.  I told myself that had been one of my 2017 Goals, so I was helping get me closer to finishing them!  The second reason I had to act now is that I needed to get 30 digital photos of Greek Hoplite miniatures to Osprey prior to May 2018 for my deadline

With that out of the way, I decided to head into the old Game Cave and find some of those projects that I still needed to paint.  Many people have a dedicated painting area where they keep all of their projects to work on.  I do not do that.  Instead, I keep everything stored and packed away.  I only pull it out when I actually intend to paint something, and when I am done I tend to pack it all away.  Thanks to this approach, I do not have many “On The Painting Desk” type moments.  This is very different from how I handle wargames, as I will get them all set-up and leave them set-up to play until I play the game, and then switch out the table for the next game I intend to play.  That is why the Messageboard has threads dedicated to what is ‘on the table” to play, but not to paint. 

So, here is what I pulled up out of the gaming area and set-up to work on this weekend,  we will see if any of it even has a brush applied to it before it ends up packed back away. 

First up we have a Spartan Games Prussian air ship.  The actual name escapes me, but it is a big one.  I will be using this for games of AeronauticaImperialis as a Varingyr Warlord Super-heavy aircraft.  You can also see four Steel Crown Valkyrie Gunships that I will also be using for Aeronautica Imperialis as Varingyr Iron Eagles with ground attack weapons.  I have painted a usable force of Varingyr using Steel Crown models, and you can see them in a number of Battle Reports on the blog.  This will just fully round the force out.  Sadly, I think Spartan Games and Steel Crown are now defunct. 



Next up, I have some Mobile Artillery Steam Tanks for All Quiet on the Martian Front.  As you can see, these still require some assembly of the metal parts.  I will need to go get some super glue for this project.  I look forward to adding them to my Minnesota Volunteer Army to help push back the Red Menace in the Minnesota River Valley campaign.  I have had these since the end of last year and I assembled the plastic parts of the kit early, I did was put off by the metal components.

 
Lastly, I have a few models for Turf War.  These are models I picked up when I ordered Pulp Alley.  I think they are called DA Thompson and the Red Queen, but I am not 100%.  Either way, they looked like they would be great models to get my gangsters started for games of Turf War.  I figured I could also use them in Strange Aeons, Pulp Alley, or Mad Dogs with Guns pretty easily.  That will make them nice versatile models once I get them painted up.

         
That is what I have on my desk for the weekend.  Typically, I tend to have more than one painting or converting project going at once so as one dries I can rotate to the others.  I normally only have a scant few minutes to paint so I try to maximize any time I can sit down and get to work.  I am hoping I can lavish some attention on these models and show some results soon.  

Monday, October 30, 2017

Random: Big News for Blood and Spectacles

This is a blog about playing and designing wargames.  Most of my posts fall into the playing category, but a few of them go into the design category too.  I have had a very productive year on the playing and design front so far, and I hope to finish the year out strong.  We will see. 

Today, I want to focus more on the design side of things than the playing.  I have a couple of big pieces of news and I wanted to share them with you, my gentle and kindly readers.  I am pretty excited about them and hopefully you will be too.


The first announcement is that Rampant Hordes is now available on the Wargames Vault for purchase.  After reading Daniel Mersey’s DuxBellorum and Lion/Dragon Rampant I always hoped he would go back and mash the two up for a Fantasy Mass Battles game.  Instead, he created something completely different with The Men WhoWould Be Kings and Pikeman’sLamentFair play to him and that forced me to get off my backside and do my own dirty work for a change. 

Rampant Hordes is inspired by Dan’s works regarding Leadership Points as a command resource, generic units augmented by Fantasy traits, and being a scale/model agnostic rules system.  Plus, I peppered in some of my own not-so secret sauce.  You know I find Innovation to be over-rated anyway.  It also took some ideas from other works such as Warmaster, Warmaster Ancients, Hail Caesar, Sword and Spear, Swordpoint, and good old DBA/DBM. 

Rampant Hordes is intended to scratch the itch that 3mm-15mm Fantasy Mass Battle itch.  The mechanics are relatively simple and straight forward.  Measurements and terrain are fairly abstract to fit a variety of battlefields from green, rolling fields, to the volcanic slopes of Mt. Ing Dredd.  Combat resolution is quick and easy with pushback mechanics moving the battle line to and fro.  In addition, you use Command Points as a resource to activate special orders, buff your troops, and keep them in the fight.  Generic units are augmented by fantasy traits to give them their own unique flavor.  Lastly, there is a battle generator and campaign to go with the game.  I find it much more fun to link a series of battles together. 

If you give the game a try, feel free to discuss it in our Messageboard.  I would love to hear about your adventures and travails.


The astute observer will notice that two other Wargames works are no longer available on the blog.  The two works in question are Menof Bronze: Ancient Greek Hoplite Battles and Heirs to Empire: Wars of the DiadochiBoth of these games were finished works.  Other astute observers will probably also notice that typically, works in the completed state that do not rely on other people’s IP typically go to the WargamesVault however neither of these works are there.  What’s up with that?  

Well, I am delighted to announce that both of these works are slated for potential release by Osprey Games.  Due to their publishing schedule it most likely will not publish until late 2019 for Men of Bronze and late 2020 for Heirs to Empire.  It may seem like a long time, but I am thankful for the delay as I must procure, paint and photograph a large number of Greek Hoplites, Macedonian Phalangites, and other fun tidbits prior to publication.  I will need that time to get all of that together and photographed to a high-standard.  I guess these Iphone photos in my basement of paper templates just won’t do! 


That wraps up the big news for today.  If you managed to snag a copy of these rules before I removed them from the Blog feel free to drop my some comments or feedback on the Messageboard.  If you have high-quality photographs of Greeks fighting Greeks that you are willing to give-up the rights to and see published drop me a comment there too. 




Thanks for all of your support and help on this journey.  As I get closer to the big day, I will probably post again about the process and a few insights gleaned here and there.            

Thursday, October 26, 2017

Random: Necromunda Pictures

This post is brought to you by two major events.  The first is found photos from my Photobucket Bail-out project.  The second is the supposed re-release of necromunda in the end of November. 

When necromunda was first released, my group of teenage misfits jumped on it right away.  We all had okay sized 40K armies, but this looked really cool and different.  I do not know how we initially got the boxset, but we did.  From there, players were picking up gangs left and right.  Some of us even had multiple gangs.  It was not uncommon for us to play multiple games in a single night with multiple gangs engaged.   

I had Cawdor as a main gang, and Eschers as a back-up.  However, it wasn't long until we had all the gangs, and multiples of some.  We even had Outlander gangs.  We diligently recorded all of our battles into an ugly blue covered notebook affectionately called in our best Space Hulk Vidoe Game voice; the Archive Record Viewer.  That was where we reviewed who had done what in a scenario, what gangers leveled up with what, and who earned what loot from the Trading Post.  It also had a list of which players ran what gangs and who were rivals of who. 

Looking back, it was this "campaign" or linked series of battles with results that carried over from one game to the next; that sealed my love of wargaming.  I still play Necromunda occassionally and look forward to the reboot.  However, I do not look forward to getting new gangers that are bigger than my old ones.  The same thing happened to me in Blood Bowl and it still makes me a bit sad. 

I have used my old Necromunda gangs for all sorts of games including Rampant Stars, Inquisitor, Da Deff Island Skirmish, Tomorrow's War, and other fun games.     

Enough rambling.  Here are some pictures of Necromunda games I found in my old Photobucket account:







I hope you enjoyed these found photos.  As you can see I have Goliaths, Orlocks, Escher, Cawdor, but I also have some Redemptionists and Scavvies too.  I also have some Demonblade Ratskin proxies too.   

Monday, October 23, 2017

Aquanautica Imperialis: Battle Report- Sea Swarm ambushes the North Ammoriss Naval PDF

The Tyranid Fleet was one of the first ones I sculpted.  I had a pretty good idea of how I wanted to approach it after struggling with the Ammoriss Naval PDF.  I had learned a few tricks of the trade and as I got better at sculpting I learned that the organic shapes of the Tyranids were actually easier to make then the hard edges of the Imperium. 

This was also one of the first forces were I tried using simple push molds and Resin casting.  Overall, I was not super pleased with the results, but as you see the fleet in battle check to see if you can find the recasts. 

Despite being one of the first fleets I had built, this will be the first time I have used it on the board.  I have no idea how it will play since I never even used it in Template form.  This should be interesting!

You can find all the rules and stuff to try it for yourself here: 

The Forces:
Ammoriss Naval PDF
AN Sovereign
Reliable Class Cruiser- 250 Points

Harpoon Squadron 486 Alpha
2 Constant Class Escorts- 150 Points

Dagger Squadron 245 Beta
2 Assured Class Escorts- 100 Points

Total= 500 Points

Tyranid Sea Swarm
Bait-
3 Atrocities- 120 Points

Reserves-
2 Abominations- 90 Points
-          Scything Talons

2 Adherrations- 150 Points
-          Submerge

1 Gruesome- 255 Points
-          Scything Talons
-          Synapse Link

Total= 615 Points


Scenario:
Today’s scenario is an Ambush mission.  In this situation, the Tyranids are using the Atrocities to lure the Human prey into chasing them into the remainder of the Sea Swarm.  The bulk of the Sea Swarm is deployed off table and in reserve.  The trick for the Ammoriss Naval PDF will be to destroy the Atrocities before being driven off by the rest of the Tyranid fleet.

********
Local fishing ships near the Alset Range had been disappearing and the locals reported it to NavComm North.  In these dark times, such reports had to be taken seriously and followed up on.  Taskforce: Divine Light had been sent to scout the area and destroy any potential threats.  NavComm feared pirates or Orks.  

Upon arriving on station, the officers began to receive troubling reports of sea monsters.  At first, it was hard to take them seriously.  However, when they were reported to the NavComm Office of Strategic Intelligence liaison the blanching of his face had to be taken seriously. 

In a private meeting with the Captain, XO, and Squadron Commanders the Liaison briefed them on the threat they faced.  After hearing about the Tyranid menace and the true danger it posed the other officers took the fisherman’s tales very, very seriously. 

A few days later, the watch officer aboard the Sovereign reported a sighting.  The flotilla changed course and gave chase.  Their spotters were able to confirm the worst as they closed in.  The Tyranids were active off the shores of North Ammoriss.
************

Set-up:
This battle will be played on a 4x4 table.  A large island is to the center north.  The Tyranid’s are in the center of the board per the scenario.  They are headed east.  The PDF are on the west side of the board along the board edge. 


Turn 1:
Initiative: Tyranids  

Move:
The Atrocities move away from the Imperial ships at full speed.  The Assureds give pursuit, while the Reliable and Constants move to go out a bit wide.  The Reliable is hoping to get them in his broadside. 

Battle:
The Atrocities spit out a screen of Gargoyles behind them who race towards the Assureds. 

The Reliable’s broadsides open up at range and through the screen at the Atrocities.  A difficult shot.  However, one shell forces the Tyranids to brace and it manages to avoid causing damage.  The Assured gunboats fire on the approaching swarm and knock one from the sky.  The Constants fire a spread of Torpedoes at the retreating Tyranid ships. 

End:
The Gargoyles move to swarm the Assureds, and the little boats will have to move through them next turn.  Meanwhile, the Torpedoes fail to lock-on to the Tyranids bio-signatures and go past. 
The only Wake marker is removed. 


Turn 2:
Initiative: PDF

Move:
The Constants change course to try and catch–up to the Atrocities  and re-load ordinance.  The Assureds also give chase.  They blast their way through the Gargoyle swarms, downing one swarm and avoiding getting damaged in return.  That was a close run thing! The Reliable continues on course to get a firing arc on the fleeing creatures. 

Meanwhile, the Tyranid reserves of a Gruesome and 2 Abominations arrive on board. 

As they flee, the Atrocities are targeted by a pair of Torpedoes again, but they fail to detonate.  The new arrivals make a bead for the human craft. 

Battle:
The Assured gunboats open fire on the Atrocities.  This time, the Atrocities fail to Brace despite the Synapse on the Gruesome.  Two of the creatures killed, and they begin to drift.  A blast of shells from the Constants sends the last creature to the bottom!

The Reliable then targets the Gruesome with a forward barrage, and two shells connect.  Will the Gruesome Brace?  It chooses not too. Two hits penetrate its shell and reduce it to 6 DP.

In return, the Gruesome launches its bio-torpedoes into the fray. 

End:
The Gargoyles turn and swarm the Assured gunboats once more.  The Point Defense splashes one, but three more attack the trailing Assured. However, the crew takes shelter and avoids the Gargoyle’s attacks. 

The Gruesome’s torpedoes get to the Constat’s but PD destroys one.  The rest flash by underneath missing their targets. 

One of the Atrocities sinks, while the other continues to drift. 

All wake is removed.


Turn 3:
Initiative: Tyranids

Move:  
The Abherrations fail to arrive.

The Gruesome goes all ahead full and smashes into a Constant.  He smashes the little ship into small pieces and sends it to the bottom.  He takes two hits in return though, sending him down to 4 DP and crippling him!  The smaller atrocities move to support the Gruesome’s attack. 

The other Constant unintentionally collides with the beast and is also sent to the bottom, but causes 1 more DP loss to the Tyranid beast.  

 The Assureds close in on the smaller Tyranid beasts and fight off the Gargoyle swarms again.  Meanwhile the Reliable stays on course and gets the Gruesome in his broadsides. 

Battle:
The abominations fire on the Reliable, and cause 1 hit.  The Captain chooses not to Brace, and the armor takes the hit.

The Reliable locks-on and opens fire on the Gruesome to finish it off.  The creature braces for the salvo, but 8 hits blast into it!  The end result after Bracing and armor is 3 DP, reducing it to a lifeless mass! 

The Assureds flank the Abominations and open fire, killing one with gunfire. 

End:
Stray PDF torpedoes hit and sink the drifting Atrocity.  The Gargoyle swarms fail to catch-up with the Assureds. 

An Abomination and the Gruesome corpses drift.


Turn 4:
Initiative: PDF

Move:
The last Abomination rams the Reliable.  They all Brace.  The Reliable ends up taking a hit, while the Abomination is destroyed in the attack. 

However, Aberrations enter play and move to a firing depth on the Assureds. 

Battle:
The only firing available is the Abherration torpedo attacks.  However, they fail their instinctive behavior checks and decide to drift instead. 

End:
The Gargoyles can not reach a target. 

The Gruesome explodes, but no one is injured.    

One abomination drifts, but the other in entangled. 


Conclusion:
The Tyranids decide to call it a battle, and that they lost.  The Abherrations would be ineffective due to the loss of their Synapse Creature with the Gruesome and would be unlikely to swing the battle in their favor.  The North Ammoriss Naval PDF would have a tough time eliminating the last two vessels so it would have been a frustrating couple of turns.     

This was the first time I have used the Tyranids so I have some observations.  This fleet plays very differently than the ones I have used in the past.  The Gruesome was surprisingly fragile!  The 6+ armor was very weak and it was no match for the PDF cruiser’s guns.  Plus, its weapons are forward firing so you need to maneuver it more carefully than I was expecting.  In addition, the poor armor made ramming not as effective as I would have hoped. 

Gargoyle Swarms are also a “go big or go home” unit.  The few I had on the board were not enough.  Also, due to their speed they can not keep up with some of the escorts they would be best at killing.  I should have kept the swarms closer to the escort bait ships in this battle to keep them as a protective screen and make them harder to hit.  That was a key learning. 

Ultimately, my lack of a Battleship class Tyranid vessel was a big weakness.  If I had used a Submerged Gruesome instead of Abherrations as it would have been more effective.  However, the improved armor and Hull of a Gargantuan or Monstrosity would have been the most effective. 

It was really fun to ram stuff!  I don’t normally do that.  Using some of the smaller Tyranid escorts as disposable rams against enemy cruisers and battleships would be great fun! I am unsure how effective such a swarm backed up by a Battleship would be, but I think it would be immensely satisfying to play.

Ultimately, the Tyranids are a very different play style than I normally play.  Next time I will have a better feel for the fleet and its playstyle.  Therefore, I will be better next time.  Maybe I can get some new Tyranid bio-ships built for it too?        
**************************************

Taskforce: Divine Light’s vox transmission came in late in the afternoon.  Like all such reports, it was processed through the enormous bureaucracy of NavComm.  Servitors and scribes transcribed it, annotated it, and data-stamped it.  It was carried by hand from adepts desk to adepts desk. 

By early evening, it had arrived at the desk for a Startego in the Office of Strategic Intelligence, deep within the bowels of NavComm North.  He read the report, and was disquieted.  The taskforce had been successful, but where there was one Tyranid bio-ship there were more.  He turned to his keypad and began typing furiously. 


Taskforce: Divine Lights job was just beginning.    

Friday, October 20, 2017

Wargame Design: Innovation is Over-rated

Yup.  I said it.  Innovation is over-rated.  I feel this is especially true in the field of wargames design.  Too many people are trying way too hard, to be way too clever.  Most of the people I see try to re-invent the wheel end up stalling their project and never getting anything to a playable state.  There is no reason to try and make games if you never have anything to play. 

 
Alternatively, they get something to a playable state, but it comes out way to different and complicated that no one wants to play it.  The players can’t wrap their heads around it, or it requires a lot of tracking, or there is too much table clutter, etc.  People read the rules, scratch their heads and never look back.  Most of the time I see someone trying to innovate a mechanic or system they spiral into If This/Then That style of rules.  Instead, keep it simple.  If you use a method to roll over a target number to resolve an action, use that same model for everything else that requires a test.  Use the same core mechanics over and over in the rules.            
 
Once, a long time ago I took a class on screen writing.  The professor shared something that stuck with me for a long time and I recognize the truth of.  He said that if you want to actually sell manuscripts for movies and books do not try to be innovative.  Many people are afraid of that which they do not understand or feel comfortable with.  Innovative ideas are not comfortable and therefore lead to a lack of buying.  Instead, take an existing model and re-skin it.  Change the setting, a plot point, or a character around.  The skeleton is the familiar, the innovation or uniqueness is how you combine the pieces.    
 
My young ears were shocked by this notion.  Then, I actually started to look around at what the entertainment industry was offering me and realized with horror that he was right.  That was exactly what was happening for the most part.  Let’s look at “arguably” the first Blockbuster movie and nerd classic; Star Wars.  There is nothing new in Star Wars.  In fact, it is very “traditional” in its narrative.  The big change was simply placing it in a new setting.  How many times has the Seven Samurai been re-done?  The innovation is putting a new spin or use on a classic idea.  People do not feel alienated by the innovation and instead embrace the subtle change or re-use. 
        

Therefore, if you want to make games that you can play don’t try to re-invent the wheel.  Innovation is over-rated.  Instead focus on what you are trying to accomplish with your game and look at what other games do to achieve it.  Do they roll to beat a target number, cross-reference a chart, use opposed rolls, use an interrupt system?  Instead of trying to invent a whole new method, use one that works and apply it to your game.  Always remember what you are trying to accomplish and you will not go wrong.
 
Someone else probably thought of it somewhere first.  That is why it is so important to stay current with new systems and games.  You will slowly create an “inventory” of mechanics that you can then apply to the design problems you face.  These ideas become your “Tool box” where you apply these mechanics together into new and interesting ways.  It is this re-combination of mechanics and how you apply them to new or different problems where you will find innovation.  It is not creating something new from whole cloth.  It is something new from the sum of its parts.
 
 
If you read the rules for Castles in the Sky, you will find that it takes liberally from several games systems.  This includes Battlefleet Gothic, Aeronautica Imperialis, Battletech, All Quiet on the Martian Front, Dystopian Wars, and a few other game systems.  In fact, if you are familiar with all of these games then you can probably tell me exactly what mechanics came from which game.  However, how they all work together is what gives the game a unique feel and play style.  Plus, it is a complete and playable game system! 
 
Too many designers focus on creating the perfect mechanic, instead of just getting on with it and making the game.  Innovation is over-rated if it stops you from completing your wargame project.  Instead, remember what you are trying to accomplish and use the existing mechanics that will allow you to get there.  The innovation will come with how the mechanics integrate together to make the sum of the game.